Blog

Brett Herriot Review

The Talented Mr. Ripley, Festival Theatre, Edinburgh Review:

*** 3 Stars

Taught and Oft Gripping! “

Patricia Highsmith’s novel, The Talented Mr. Ripley marked its 70th anniversary this year following its debut in 1955 it would go on to global recognition thanks to the 1999 motion picture adaptation directed by Anthony Minghella starring Matt Damon and Jude Law.

Following the most recent 2024 television adaption for Netflix, the psychological thriller comes to the stage for the first time in a taught and oft gripping production adapted and directed by Mark Leipacher and it makes a stop at the Edinburgh Festival Theatre for a weeklong run to kick off the venue’s autumn programme of plays.

The cast are sublime especially the leads with Ed McVey taking on the title role of Tom Ripley and Bruce Herbelin-Earle as Dickie Greenleaf respectively telling the story of Ripley a Conman who gets in over his head went sent to Italy to induce Greenleaf into returning home to the United States at his father’s requests. Ripley finds deeply hidden emotions rekindled as he swept along by Greenleaf’s playboy lifestyle. Leading to killer consequences as we discover is it ever truly possible to get away with murder and live with the guilt.

McVey and Herbelin-Earle are truly capturing in the roles making use of the many opportunities to break the fourth wall as McVey often Narrates the story as well giving the character of Ripley a multi-dimensional personality. Special mention must also go to Maisie Smith (yes, she has left the angst of Walford and Eastenders far behind) as Marge Sherwood. Marge is Dickie Greenleaf lover but is snared in Ripley’s web of lies as she tries to discover the truth, and Smith gives an impassioned performance.  The principal cast are joined by a seven strong ensemble who bring to live the dozens of characters that inhabit the world of Ripley and they do so with incredible talent although there are odd occasions were accents are not what they should be.

Production wise it’s a stripped back affair with Holly Pigott’s set and costume design being clearly influenced by acclaimed west end and Broadway director Jamie Lloyd, with lighting bars exposed and the bulk of the action centred on a raised platform centre stage. Zeynep Kepekli’s lighting design leans into the overall design incredibly well but the moments of blinding light that evokes golden era Hollywood does become jarring due to excessive use. 

Max Pappenheim’s sound design should work on paper but on the execution on press night there were major problems with the sound operation. It’s clear the cast are wearing microphones but there not always on when they should be or there popping and banging at will. The sound balance also needs looking at as there is a soundscape in the show, but the balance is off kilter so much, so members of the audience were checking to ensure their mobile phones were off having not realised its the sound within the show before them.

The Talented Mr. Ripley offers an engaging night of drama with polished performances throughout along with a pace that whips along but the technical elements need to match that standard to bring the show up to the four star that’s clearly with in it.

Have you felt like someone was watching you? well check out The Talented Mr. Ripley to see a chilling reflection of that often-Macabre feeling.

The Talented Mr. Ripley, Festival Theatre, Edinburgh The production runs until Saturday 20th September then the UK tour continues, for more info go to: https://www.capitaltheatres.com/shows/the-talented-mr-ripley/

Mary Woodward Review

The Railway Children, Keighley & Worth Valley Railway, Review

***** (5 stars)

“A marvel of such miracles”

What better way to start a railway adventure than by eating steak and kidney pudding in the Old Parcels Office at Keighley Station and then riding in a carriage pulled by a heavily chuffing steam locomotive up the short but at times pretty steep incline and past the iconic Oakworth station to Oxenhope station (660 feet above sea level, it says) where the performance takes place in the engine shed?

Before the performance begins, there’s plenty of time to investigate the delights available in the area surrounding the station courtyard: a mouth-watering choice of hot pies, snacks, sweets and other treats, Railway Children souvenirs, and drinks of all kinds: I succumbed to the lure of Thunder and Lightning ice cream, and was not disappointed…

And then it was time to enter the Engine Shed – which I last visited towards the end of last year to see the KWVR’s incredible production of Dickens’ A Christmas Carol which began and ended in this shed, but moved to a [moving] steam-hauled train for the intervening scenes.  At that time we were surrounded by locomotives: now we entered a blacks-hung area in which tiers of seating faced each other across a section of railway track.  At one end there was a typical railway bridge and hint of a signal box: at the other the corner of a stationmaster’s house, beside a black tunnel leading who knows where… 

Bridging the track/gap between the rows of seating at one point was an area of wooden planking on which sat some black trunks.  This simple grouping was our first view of the absolutely marvellous set design – in essence extremely simple but capable of extreme versatility thanks to four superbly agile blue-clad ‘railway workers’ – uncredited, but fully deserving their huge applause at the final curtain.  

It wasn’t immediately obvious that this small area of planking was on a trolley on wheels which could be moved up and down the rail tracks which lay between our two tiers of seating.  The flexibility and versatility of scenes and props this enabled was a stroke of design genius: not only scenery but cast members could swiftly be moved in and out of our view, and new scenes set up out of sight and magically brought into view when required.  Fabulous [especially the landslide]!

The whole show was a marvel of such miracles, and brought smiles to all the faces intently watching and engrossed in the action playing out in front of them.  The lighting is superb, and the sound effects and music fit quite wonderfully into the drama, heightening the emotion where appropriate, but never, ever, going over the top or playing for cheap effect.  Altogether, it’s an outstanding production – a wonderful collaboration between playwright Mike Kenny and director Damian Cruden.

The story is fairly simple.  Three ordinary children – Roberta [Bobby], Peter and Phyllis – lived with their mother and father in an ordinary house with ordinary but not always nice servants and an ordinaryish mother and father.  Mother stayed at home, and father went out to work and “did something”, working for the government “to keep you all safe”: it was all very nice and, by repetition, ordinary.

Peter’s birthday, however, was far from ordinary.  Cake with candles had been brought [and blown out] when the doorbell rang.  Mysterious fragments of conversation, half-heard, ensued, and father came back to say “I’ve been called away … on business”.  Life becomes increasingly far from ordinary.  The servants leave one by one, and suddenly mother and the children pack up, leave their house, and set off for Yorkshire. All the children are told, in essence, is that “it’s not necessary for you to know anything about anything” – all they know is that mother is very unhappy and that it’s best to avoid asking any questions or talking about anything that adds to that unhappiness.

The children find life hard at first – anything they say is met with “you’re not from round here, are you?” and they become painfully aware that they are very poor – but slowly they make friends, especially with Oakworth stationmaster Perks and, when mother falls ill, with the doctor.  Their one solace is visiting the nearby railway every day, and waving to the Black Dragon, the 9.15 London train which takes their love to father.

The Old Gentleman on the train, a persecuted Russian author trying to find his wife and children, a coal-mining expedition which could have ended in disaster, a wounded [human] hound and an averted railway disaster weave their way through this narrative of adjusting to new surroundings and attendant hardships, finding friendship and help in unexpected places, and the strength of family [even when they drive you mad].

The narrative is framed by the three children, now grown up, who look back and play out the scenes from their memories – as with all families, disagreeing about the details!  It’s only in the final scene that we see Bobby, Peter and Phyllis at the ages they were at the time of their Railway Adventure, which allows a more intense dramatic experience than if the three were their ‘actual’ age.

The whole cast is superb.  Even before the show officially begins, we are invited to engage with the actors, being waved at and waving as they walk along the edges of the ‘platforms’ in front of our seats.  By the time the action begins we have become part of it rather than detached spectators waiting to be entertained: when we finally get to play a part, the whole audience acts as one, joyfully.

All the cast, from youngest to oldest, were superb – a fantastic team effort that was still completely fresh despite having been on show at least once a day, and often twice, from the end of July.  The minor parts were all beautifully presented, with much doubling up of ‘crowd’, ‘villagers’, travellers and other such parts,  and a lively ‘hare’ and ‘hounds’.   I was particularly taken with the performances of the ‘grown up’ Bobby, Peter, and Phyllis – Farah Ashraf, Raj Digva and Jessica Kaur: but everyone was excellent!

The show had so many marvellous moments I could be here for hours telling you about them, but I’ll try to be brief.  One of the most magical was the way we entered the tunnel to find out what had become of the injured hound in the local boys’ school’s ‘hare and hounds’ race – another stroke of complete genius, very simple and supremely effective.  Others: the “very long and boring” speech made by an unnamed official at the presentation ceremony after the averted disaster; the magic tricks and unexpected behaviour of the Russian emigré; Perks’ transformation from outraged repudiator of what he sees as charity to generous acceptor of birthday gifts from well-wishers; the wonderful music that built up to and accompanied some dramatic moments and the lovely song to celebrate Bobby’s birthday; and many, many more.

But the crowning moment for me, the real tears-in-the-eyes one for a lifetime lover of steam locomotives, is the first appearance in front of us of locomotive 52044, who glides towards the three children who are furiously waving red flannel petticoats, trying to stop the train from crashing into the landslide which has covered the tracks…

I was only able to see this show on the antepenultimate night – the run ends on Sunday: had I the time, I would rush to see it again immediately.  As it is, I’ll have to wait and hope that this incredibly and deservedly popular show makes its way back to the KWVR next summer.  Fingers crossed!

The Railway Children, Keighley & Worth Valley Railway, Runs until Sunday 7th September for more information go to: https://kwvr.co.uk/railway-children/

Arts News!, Brett Herriot at the Festivals, Mary Woodward at the Festivals

Thank you! The curtain falls on the 2025 Edinburgh Festivals Season!

“The greatest platform for the arts in the world!”

Three weeks and four weekends spanning July 30th through August 25th has seen the annual cultural explosion that is the festivals season taking over the Scottish Capital as Edinburgh welcomes the globe and re-establishes itself as the greatest platform for the arts in the world!

The two-person team here at Scotsgayarts.com received thousands of emails from companies performing across the Edinburgh Fringe, The international Festival and the Book Festival.  These were whittled down to the hundred or so reviews that have been published on the site across the duration of the festivals.

Our coverage has spanned the Edinburgh Fringe, The Edinburgh International Festival, The Edinburgh Book Festival, The Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo, The PHB free festival and even the Film Festival got a look in.

As the festivals continue to grow and expand there is ongoing debate on all sides as to the impact both negatively and positively for the city which hosts these acclaimed events. The 2025 festival season was also affected by the nearly 300,000 music fans attending both Oasis and AC/DC concerts hosted at Murrayfield Stadium not to mention even more pop concerts hosted at the Royal Highland Showgrounds at Ingliston.

Just how much can one city take from tourism? Can it withstand these pressures? it appears that for 2025 at least Edinburgh has come through it in fine shape but there may well still be a cost to bare. Not every show that was offered across the festivals program enjoyed healthy audiences and many dreams will lie shattered, that however is the nature of the beast.

The one thing that is clear is the formula isn’t working for far too many and discussion is needed across the festival organizers going forward and more importantly the city council and the citizens of this great city to secure the cultural phenomenon for both performers, producers, venues, the city and its people on a shared equal footing for generations to come.  

As the curtain falls on this year’s festivals, we at Scotsgayarts.com offer our profound thanks to all those who shared their work with us, each and every moment spent in venues that spanned small intimate theatres to the grandeur of the tattoo arena at Edinburgh Castle provided magical theatrical moments that will stay with us for a lifetime.

The Arts matter and Scotsgayarts.com is indebted to the creatives who shared their work and themselves and make the festivals just what they are! We now move forward into the autumn and winter season of work from across Scotland, but we are already pondering with excitement what the 2026 Festival season will bring our way!

For now, rest well, thank you and haste ye back!

Brett

Editor

Scotsgayarts.com

Brett Herriot at the Festivals

Sweeney Todd, Spiegeltent at the Famous Spiegeltent Venue 333, Review:

***** (5 stars)

“A Steampunk driven triumph!”

Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street is often sighted as Stephen Sondheim’s greatest work and has stood the test of time since its debut 46 years ago at the Uris Theatre on Broadway. Featuring music and lyrics by Sondheim and a book by Hugh Wheeler based upon the earlier 1970 play by Christopher Bond. This is the Victoria penny opera that deals with redemption, revenge and truth in the most macabre of ways.

Captivate Theatre return to the show with a brand-new production housed at the also returning Famous Spiegeltent in St Andrews Square and my word the production is nothing less than a Steampunk driven triumph.

Sweeney is a timeless tale that still resonates and thanks to most accomplished company of performers to be found at the Fringe your drawn into a dark underworld that’s peppered with outstanding performances from Top to Bottom.

Leading this most extraordinary of casts is Robert Moyes in the role of Sweeney who delivers a dark and brooding interpretation soaked with blood lust in a performance that captures from the off. The immense talent of Hazel Beattie is brought to bear in the titular role of “Mrs. Lovett” she mines every moment of comic nuance in a true tour de force performance. Special mention must also go to Alex Fraser (who alternates with Seamus Cross) as “Toby” he creates a performance imbued with innocence and truth that makes his final moments all the more shocking. The twenty-one strong ensemble company are utterly faultless and perform with a raw intensity never before seen at the festivals.

Director Sally Lyall has delivered the goods in spectacular style and her understanding of the source material is clearly faultless and she makes the most of the Victorian splendor of the Spiegeltent to enhance a cleverly stripped back staging of the show. This is boosted by Charlotte Nicholson’s cleverly steampunk infused wardrobe design.  The icing on the cake is musical director Colum Findlay’s 9 strong pit orchestra who clearly revel in the most intricate of scores.

Captivates Sweeney Todd was a spectacular grand finale to the 2025 festival season and truly showcased the depth and quality of talent with in the company it was joy to attend the tale let us all hope the invite goes out again for the 2026 Festival as this is a Sweeney Todd that needs to be seen to be believed.

Sweeney Todd, Spiegeltent at the Famous Spiegeltent Venue 333, RUN ENDED for info go to: https://www.edfringe.com/tickets/whats-on/sweeney-todd

Mary Woodward at the Festivals

Delusional – I Killed a Man, Main Hall at Summerhall, (Venue 26), Review

**** (4 stars)

“Immense personal courage”

As we enter the theatre we are greeted by a ravishingly beautiful young woman in a splendidly Victorian black dress, who thanks us for coming today.

We are seated: she moves centre stage, and thanks us again for coming to the funeral.  Spotlit, draped in a transparent black veil, she moves towards the light streaming from an open door.  She raises a glowing white handkerchief and lets it fall to the ground: we are plunged into darkness.

Diana Salles demonstrates not only extraordinary physical dance and circus skills but also immense personal courage as she invites us into her world, to being to have an inkling of what it’s like to be a trans woman.  Change is an inevitable and essential part of everyone’s life, but not everyone can face up to, adapt to necessary change with such naked honesty.

The time we spend with her is full of joy and beauty, but also pain and struggle, with moments of humiliation and despair among the glitter and glamour.  Words, music, light, spectacle all make their contribution to Diana’ story: through it all her strength and determination carry her onwards.

So many incredible moments.  The whole first section, with scarlet cloths streaming around a huge hoop; Diana peeling away layers and layers of restrictive mourning clothes and finally swinging free.  Free of the restrictions of gravity, free to defy expectations and climb, plummet, twist and swing as though she had wings…  Gathering up all the scarlet cloth after it’s fallen to the ground, cradling it tenderly, caressing the wee ‘child’ in her arms…  The tensions between the feminine and masculine body language and ways of walking… The incredible grace of her feet and toes when she’s on the ground and in the air…  The clash between the pouring out of grief and the feistiness of the warrior…

The final image is the one I want to remember – Diana, now clad in a shiny pink frock with a wonderfully exuberant skirt whirls round and round, a radiant smile on her face, as rose petals fall from the ceiling.  Proud and joyful, we join her in celebrating her life and the truth she has chosen to manifest.

A standing ovation is the only possible reaction.

Delusional – I Killed a Man, Main Hall at Summerhall, (Venue 26), RUN ENDED for more information go to: https://www.edfringe.com/tickets/whats-on/delusional-i-killed-a-man