***** (5 stars)
“Gorgeous!”
I’ll be honest: I asked for a ticket for this concert because I’m a great fan of Sheku Kanneh-Mason and really enjoy his visits to the International Festival. Add to this the inducement of hearing a Schubert quintet [the one in C, D.956] and what’s not to like? Yes, there was also a Bartók piano quintet [the one in C, Sz.23] on the programme, and I’m less keen on his music – but it’s good to be challenged aurally, yes?
Oh gosh I’m so glad I got a ticket for this recital – it was a joy from the first note to the very last. I was familiar with the Schubert but didn’t know the Bartók at all. I’m so very glad the Kleio Quartet approached Nicola Benedetti with the idea of putting these two works together – both are in C major, but sound quite different. There’s less than a century between them [1828 and 1904]: the Schubert is one of his last works, the Bartók his first piano quintet, written in his early 20s. What links them both is the passion that surges through both of them – which today’s performers gave us in full measure.
A string quartet consists of two violins, a viola and a cello – so what’s the fifth instrument here? In this case, Yume Fujise, Katherine Yoon, Jaren Ziegler and Gerard Flotats were joined by Sheku Kanneh-Mason the engaging and charismatic young cellist who won BBC Young Musician of the Year in 2016. I was interested to see quite how this instrumental lineup would work – and fascinated by the way Schubert saw the additional cello as a soloist who could hold forth on his own, engage in dialogue with other individual instruments, blend seamlessly into the ensemble, and at times provide a wonderful rhythmical pizzicato backing to the quartet.
The quartet’s sound in the Schubert was warm, lush and Viennese – like a slice of Sachertorte covered in whipped cream. Sheku’s cello got to sing, but never overpowered the Kleio quartet, who work seamlessly and delightfully together – small wonder they won the first prize and commission prize at the 2023 Carl Neilsen chamber music competition! I know this Schubert piece well, and frequently listen to it at home – but it’s a totally different experience hearing it live, in the company of a Queens Hall full of intently listening music lovers. Each individual line can be heard more clearly, and the emotions connect audience and musicians so much more deeply as we listen to a fascinating five-way conversation in which each individual gets a chance to shine, is listened to intently, and gives generous support to the others when it’s their turn in the spotlight.
There’s gorgeous tone, sensitive phrasing, wonderful dynamic contrast, impressively nuanced dynamics and some glorious pizzicato, especially in the first movement and moving into the second. There’s strong emotion, even storms, and always the return to elegant, graceful melody. A vibrantly exciting third movement in which a lively, galloping melody bounces between the players leads into a muted autumnal lament which is itself followed by such a lively dance in triple time that a very large portion of the audience, myself included, couldn’t help but burst into enthusiastic applause at the end of the movement.
And that wasn’t the end of things – the fourth movement was equally full of delights, with a dance that seemed almost military in its precision alternating with a gleamingly golden waltz. The pace picked up, the music became lighter and jollier, and faster and faster until a final flourish had the audience erupting with delight, their applause so loud and prolonged it was clear they didn’t want the five musicians ever to leave the stage.
In the second half the quartet were joined by pianist Makoto Ozone. His jazz career, which spans over forty years, has earned him a Grammy nomination and seen him work with many prominent jazz musicians. In more recent years he’s started playing classical concertos by Mozart, Bernstein and Prokofiev.
In her introduction to the second half of the programme, first violinist Yume Fujise commented that as classically trained musicians, she and her colleagues were always seeking perfection. Working with Makoto reminded them that perfection should not be the first aim – conveying the emotions in the music should be paramount. That was clearly the case in this performance of Bartók’s first piano quintet.
The quartet’s tone was still warm, but steelier than in the Schubert – maybe dark hot chocolate infused with chilli this time, and hold the cream…
The music was lush and romantic, but also spiky; infused with both fury and passion. It’s another conversation, but with a different sort of dynamic – the strings sing, and the piano is more percussive: though it can also blend in and be an integral, rather than a separate, part of the conversation. My notes say fiery and romantic at the same time, stormy, brooding, yearning, galloping, becoming menacing, with spiky harmonics: and this is just the first movement!
The second movement had some fascinating rhythmic oddities among a lot of lively dancing in triple time – there was almost a competition between piano and strings, as if they were trying to play nicely together but simply couldn’t quite manage it. The third movement had some wonderfully sonorous chords with an almost subterranean, underwater piano sound. A warm bath of sound, a singing romantic outpouring together, a piano solo floating like fireflies in the darkness while the strings surge underneath moving into some extremely lively folk dances which whirled into a riotous party – as the movement title says poco a poco più vivace – little by little more lively. The pace got faster and faster, with a stunning finale to which the only possible reaction was a storm of applause even louder than that which greeted the end of the first piece.
What a treat! What a joy! Haste ye back, lovely musicians!
Kleio Quartet and Sheku Kanneh-Mason, Edinburgh International Festival, Queens Hall, Run Ended for more information go to: Kleio Quartet, Makoto Ozone & Sheku Kanneh-Mason | Edinburgh International Festival