Category: Mary Woodward Review

***** (5 stars)

“Delightful and Passionate”

Yik Liang Soo, Khalil Johnson and Elze Fedorcovaite are the Chiara trio, who made their first visit to Northesk parish church as part of the ‘Music at the Brunton’ series.  ‘Chiara’ is Italian for ‘clear’: on a lovely sunny day the trio brought their clear, strong, and equal voices to their performance of trios by Haydn and Dvòrăk.

I’m more familiar with Haydn’s string quartets, which are delightful and encompass the full range of emotions – frequently sunny and joyful, occasionally moving into ‘the darker side of things’ but never really hitting the depths of anguish.  This G minor trio was written in 1794, when Haydn was 61: its jaunty start had an underlying melancholy – a cloudier day with occasional gleams of sunshine.  As the piece went on, I was aware of the constant visual communication between the three players – and, increasingly, the subservient part the cello was playing while the violin and piano took turns to shine…  Asked about this afterwards, cellist Khalil Johnson said ‘yes, but I’m really the important one – the rhythm section on which the other two build’ – and that’s very true! 

The Dvòrăk F minor trio is a considerably more substantial piece, with some fascinating key changes.  It begins and ends in F minor, with a move to the relative major, Ab – but the second movement is in C# minor – a slightly off-the-wall choice, but a most interesting one.  Written after the composer’s ‘Slavonic’ period, in which he used many folk tunes, and before the famous ‘Dumky’ trio, this is a dark, dramatic and powerful piece, possibly reflecting the composer’s emotions following his mother’s death.

Here the three musicians put their hearts and souls into the music, pouring out passionate, fluctuating emotions which tumbled and soared and wove around each other.  Rising and falling, dramatic outbursts alternated with tranquil moments and gleams of sunshine in the turbulent storms.  Elze’s piano rippled and thundered, Yik’s violin soared and wept, Khalil’s cello rumbled and grumbled and then burst out into gloriously clear and noble melodies.  There was no subservience here – each voice had its turn to shine in the spotlight and then dance with the others in an unending conversation with occasional gleams of sunshine on the crests of waves in a dark and stormy sea.

This magnificent performance was greeted with a veritable storm of applause, richly deserved, and prolonged – we really didn’t want these three immensely talented youngsters to leave us.  Our reward came with the perfect encore – a delicate, sunny, slightly cheeky fun bagatelle by English composer Frank Bridge.  It was a joy to see three friends having such fun together – I really do hope they return to Musselburgh very very soon!

Chiara Trio, The Brunton at Northesk,, Run Ended

***** (5 stars)

“A Fabulous Exploration”

I’d booked for this concert by the Maxwell Quartet, looking forward to an evening of classical string quartet music interspersed with a little traditional Scottish music.

During Thursday I received an email saying that the quartet’s violinist Colin Scobie was unwell.  Someone else would be stepping in at short notice and so the programme would include rather more traditional music than originally planned.

I arrived at the church, rejoicing yet again in the prospect of sitting close to the musicians and listening to intimate music in a building with a wonderful acoustic.  The quartet came on stage and a very laid-back performance began.  Cellist Duncan Strachan began by welcoming us to the church and introducing Scott Bryant to us, thanking him for being available at extremely short notice.  Throughout the evening it was impossible to believe that Scott had only had less than 24 hours to prepare – you would have thought he was an integral and long-standing part of the group.

We were treated to a wonderful mixture of Scottish traditional music arranged by the quartet themselves, who took it in turn to tell us what we would hear next and a little bit about some of the pieces.  The Maxwells have taken their music to many schools in the area as part of their project Bridging East Lothian, and I’m sure were as well-received as they were here.  In homage to the locality, they included As I cam in by Fisher Row, after which we had a whistle-stop tour of Scotland [and a brief foray over the water to Ireland] with a glorious mixture of reels, jigs and laments and a wonderfully cheeky [but noble] pipe march.

Violinist George Smith and violist Elliot Perks took turns with Duncan and Scott introducing the music.  As well as telling us where the tunes were from we were treated to some fine tales.  Macintosh’s  Lament dates from the 1500s, a song sung by a grieving widow whose husband, in trying to nullify a prophecy, dies tragically on his way home from the wedding.   Fr John McMillan of Barra, a friendly giant of a man, hirpled gaily around the island and disappeared into the distance.  Haripol, one of the fictitious estates in the novels John MacNab by John Buchan and Andreew Greig’s ‘spin-off’  Return of John NacNab was celebrated in a fast and furious dance as three friends rushed across Scotland trying to poach a salmon, a brace of grouse and a deer without getting caught.   The long-running feud between the Campbells and the McGregors included a Romeo and Juliet-style tragedy: McGregor’s Lament bewails the plight of the young woman whose lover is beheaded by her angry family.

In all this music, the four musicians were clearly loving playing together, relishing the conversation they were having, and delighting in the music which three of them have been playing since they were young.  The jigs and reels had many of us tapping our feet, nodding our heads, and relishing the lively rhythms – had we not been sitting in pews, surely some of us would have got up to dance…  The arrangements were superb, widely varied and perfectly expressing the emotions of the widely-differing tunes – a clear invitation to investigate further the magnificent treasure that is Scotland’s traditional music.

The final piece, Hector the hero, was quieter; a fitting end to the concert which was greeted with that true silence of appreciation which is better than any amount of thunderous applause.  There was, of course, loud applause – and most especially for Scott Bryant’s superb playing – as I’ve said, you’d never have known he had less than a day to learn all the music.

We were thanked for coming, and invited both to the Maxwell’s next concert at the Corn Exchange in Haddington in April, and if we had time, to hang around and chat with the quartet after the performance.   I took them up on the offer and was delighted to spend some time with their violist, Englishman Elliott Perks.  He had remarked during the evening on the crash course in Scottish history and traditional music he’d undertaken after joining the quartet, and I had a wide-ranging conversation with him, starting with wondering about the reasons for the difference between Scottish and English folk music.  I’d spent my youth singing and playing English and American-English folk songs [and lived in the south of England] – moving to Scotland and experiencing the much wilder landscape and learning history from the Scottish perspective sheds much light on why and how the differences have arisen.

A brilliant evening!  I’m sorry that Colin Scobie was unwell and hope that he’s better soon – but at the same time I’m so glad that circumstances dictated the change of programme and brought us such a fabulous exploration of Scottish traditional music.  Rock on the next Maxwell’s concert, whatever the programme !!

Music at the Brunton: Maxwell Quartet – Bridging East Lothian, Northesk Parish Church, Musselburgh, RUN ENDED

***** (5 stars)

“Simply Phenomenal”

Oh the joy of having a cinema in Musselburgh!  Since the closure of the Brunton itself, due to the ‘wrong kind of concrete’, the little theatre on Loretto school’s campus has been serving as a replacement cinema and theatre for many of the Brunton’s events.  I was delighted to go there last night to see the Bob Dylan film, A complete unknown – and also delighted to be treated by my companion to a drink from the well-stocked fridges in the theatre’s foyer.

The film itself was fascinating.  As someone who grew up in that era, learned to play the guitar and spent many many hours singing folk songs with my friends Frances and Christina, I was instantly transported back in time: it was with difficulty at times that I refrained from joining in the so-very-familiar songs….

Having learned that my guitar style needed to be pretty simple if I were to be able to remember the 22 verses of Matty Groves in the right order, I was transfixed by Timothee Chalamet’s guitar-playing.  Apparently this is an accurate representation of Dylan’s unique and complex style – and Chalamet also plays the harmonica and sings [and speaks] with Dylan’s accent and intonation, all of which are instantly recognisable.  ‘Amazing’ doesn’t do the actor justice – he’s simply phenomenal!

The narrative is not particularly accurate in its details, but the film does a brilliant job of portraying life in the mid-60s.  The growth of the folk movement, protesting the way things were and calling for change; the astonishingly rapid rise to the very heights of this completely unknown young man who was only nineteen when he met Pete Seeger; the very casual nature of life and relationships within the youth of the day; the contrast and conflict between the ‘old guard’ folk purists and those who wanted the music to move into the 20th century; the pressure on Dylan of the demands of both the public and the record companies and financial backers; the incredible self-absorption and self-belief which drove Dylan continually to move forward and change his style as he sought to express what he wanted to say; and above all the sheer genius of his song-writing; all these come over so clearly and make for a marvellous evening out.

All this joy – and then a short walk home instead of a long walk, a long wait, and a long bus journey back out of town: what’s not to love about ‘the Brunton cinema’ in Musselburgh?!

Film: A Complete Unknown, The Brunton at Loretto Theatre, Musselburgh, Run Ended